Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Risky to Report Website Vulns

The main reason I stopped reporting vulnerabilities to website owners is the risk of being prosecuted.  The Internet is more dangerous when well-meaning security researchers are treated this way.  I was new to Application Security in 2006, so I didn't realize that I was actually taking a pretty big risk when I told Netflix about their CSRF vulnerabilities.  In my mind I was doing them a favor.  They got a free mini pen test.  In fact as a Netflix subscriber, I was giving them money!  It turns out they were nice and simply said "thank you", then went about fixing the issue.

Today I ran across Patrick Webster's story from Australia and he wasn't so lucky.  He noticed that his bank's web application allowed for any customer to view another customer's account information, including very sensitive data that could allow for identity theft.  This type of insecure direct object reference vulnerability is very simple to exploit.  Mr. Webster just changed a numerical parameter in the URL to discover the problem.  He reported it to his bank, who decided to report him to the police.  It's not like this guy was a determined attacker with premeditation who spent weeks doing reconnaissance on the site.  That said, he clearly went too far by running a script that "cycled through each ID number and pulled down the relevant report to his computer".  That wasn't necessary to report the vulnerability.

Another example is Andrew Auernheimer who is potentially facing 5 years in prison due to his AT&T "account slurper" script.  Again, he went too far with the script, but clearly he might've been prosecuted anyway.  One of the comments on this story was humorous:

You seem to be implying that every exploit can be anticipated. The article points out that AT&T changed their code after discovery of the hack. There is no indication that they knew it was a problem before hand.
Web app vulns can and should be anticipated.

2 comments:

Dave Ferguson 1/26/2013 1:16 PM  

Here is another example. Canadian college student Ahmed Al-Khabaz was expelled from his school because he notified them about a serious vulnerability in a web application supplied by a 3rd party. Veracode's co-founder Chris Wysopal comments on this story as well. http://securityledger.com/students-expulsion-exposes-computer-science-culture-gap/.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP